Nice but needs some upgrades to be great

Tv's need replaced. And beds were pretty hard.

Very nice hotel with friendly staff. Perfect for a short - long stay. Highly recommend!!

Friendly staff, large and clean rooms, nice amenities.

No concerns here.

Always and consistently a fantastic place to stay. No concerns and great breakfast.

In forty-five years of travel, I am confident in saying the Carlisle is the cleanest, quietest, incredibly well run hotel where I've had the pleasure of staying. If a sixth-star rating we're available, thats what I would rate it. A Gary & Lisa Led, six day stay

Fantastic location and employees!

Everything was clean and accommodating. Staff is always friendly. Every time I visit Sarasota I stay here. Highly recommend staying here.

Great Place to Stay

Wonderful place to stay! Clean, comfortable, and friendly. The room was huge. The beds were very comfortable and the other amenities were in good condition. Highly recommend.

Front desk staff superb!

Amazing staff and very clean

Excellent customer service, very friendly staff. Beautiful hotel! Super clean and comfortable. Also, excellent breakfast! Will definitely come back to stay!

Beautiful! Well maintaned! Excellent service!

Everything was wonderful

Stayed one night, front desk staff very friendly, took the time to explain the surroundings! , Room was clean & comfortable. Would highly recommend the Inn. 😀

Very clean. Excellent service and hospitality.

Friendly and helpful staff. The hotel had beach chairs you could borrow free of charge to take to the beach. The hotel breakfast was very good. I would definately stay her again.

Best place to stay

This is one of our favorite places to stay.

Excellent staff, excellent facility, excellent amenities, excellent all around. So happy to have found this gem.

Very clean , pleasant staff’ spacious rooms

Spacious room with 2 sinks and a great breakfast

top stay!

Very nice hotel

Very comfortable stay! The staff were all very friendly and helpful and our room was big, clean, and very comfortable. Breakfast was good and parking was easy. Would stay again!

Staff was very friendly, all of them always. Very very clean!!!

Family oriented, clean, friendly and helpful staff, one stop shop for dining, gifts, bakery, etc. I would definitely stay here on my next visit.

Best place i ever visit..

By far one of the bicesr hotels in Florida

The Carlisle Inn is our absolute favorite. The cleanest hotel we’ve ever stayed at. So quiet and safe and with the best baked goods! Friendly staff all around.

Always clean welcoming and the breakfast is great.

The best Hotel I have ever stayed at. I have stayed at many different 3, 4 & 5-Star hotels and I found this one the best one so far. It is so clean, and smells awesome! Very well organized, hotel staffs are so welcoming and friendly, all amenities are very clean and readily available. I love this hotel and will come again with my family. I recommend this place to everyone!

What a beautiful place to relax for a few days! Clean, comfortable, and quiet! The staff was very friendly & made our stay perfect.

Great service; breakfast was not great but hard to expect more.

One of the cleanest well appointed hotels in Florida

Lovely spacious room, large & diverse breakfast, afternoon cookies, a clean good-sized pool & jacuzzi, gym, dressing room with showers, plenty of parking, & a hearty restaurant with fresh Amish pies & apple butter (including no-sugar!)

Very clean

The reviews were right……this lave is spotless

Very clean and safe

Very clean, friendly service, and nice pool.

Wonderful place to stay

A wonderful experience!

Size of room was great!

Always wonderful!

Staff was great and hotel was very clean and beautiful. Hall ways and rooms were very spacious.

Very clean, safe, and comfortable.

It was our favorite place by far! We stayed with our 3 kids and we all want to go back again. The breakfast was the best by far and the staff goes above and beyond!

Nice, clean

Great stay! Big rooms that were clean and comfortable. Would recommend.

Property was quite, safe, clean. Room was kept very clean. Except the breakfast was the only let down. Was terrible for the level this hotel maintains. Rest of the staff, room etc was very good.

Very nice and clean.

Super clean. Respectful staff. Quiet and relaxing. Definitely stay again

This is our favorite place to stay when visiting Sarasota. I cannot say enough wonderful things about The Carlisle!

Great hotel!

Highly Recommend

Our family loved this hotel. Large rooms, very clean, nice breakfast and there were cookies in the evening. Staff was extremely helpful and kind.

We were pleased with the whole experience. High compliments to the Carlisle Inn in Sarasota.

Great place!

Great place with location close to downtown. Everyone who works here are super nice and helpful.

Property is beautiful and well maintained. It has really large rooms and hallways. I would stay there again.

The Carlisle Inn is an outstanding hotel. It is exceptionally clean, quiet and although they have a wonderful breakfast spread, it is a convenient walk to an excellent restaurant. The staff is friendly and extremely helpful. A five-star experience for sure!

Spacious facility

All good here, amish know hospitality.

The hotel is nice and clean, my family of 4 enjoyed the 2 night stay in the double bed room. The heated pool area was nice as well as all common areas in the hotel. There are a couple of things that could be better though - the breakfast was very basic, with rubbery scrambled eggs made out of egg powder. Another thing that we didn’t enjoy was smell in the room - it had very chemical smell of cleaning supplies. Overall, it’s a very nice hotel though.

Enjoyed my stay.

Very clean and comfortable

A very clean modern property with friendly staff

This property is always outstanding. The rooms are always clean and the front desk staff are very friendly and helpful. Best breakfast!

This is the best hotel you can ever stay in, in your life, if you are in the area, book it the people are amazing the hotel is first class !

Best hotel on FL west coast!

The hotel was absolutely amazing! I will be only staying here when back again for business!

The Carlisle is my new favorite place to stay in Sarasota.

Staff promptly checked breaker when outlets were not working. Would recommend

10/10. One of the best hotels I’ve ever stayed at. The hotel is immaculate. The rooms are huge. They do daily room cleaning, something that’s rare these days. They have free cookies every night. The hotel is next to a huge smorgasboard bakery gift store.

Clean and courteous!

Not many restaurants and the area is like dead location. Not worth the price

Nice and clean. Friendly people

The breakfast is ok cannot be rate as more than 3 star

Muy bueno , gran atención y muy limpio

Spotless

What a wonderful surprise! Beautiful hotel completed decorated throughout.

Very clean and attractive property. Large, comfortable room. Pleasant decor. Generous, delicious complimentary breakfast. Reasonable rates.

This is a highly recommended stay, at an excellent price! Wonderful large room, with bottles of water waiting for us. The first bathroom we have ever experienced that provided two separate rooms, divided by the entrance hall, toilet\shower in one with its own vanity\sink. The other one also had a vanity sink, fridge, microwave and the big walk-in closet together, so perfect for a couple to do different things separately. 👍 We thought brilliant planning! The rest of the room was very spacious with larger than average widescreen TV. ✅

Very nice staff and clean rooms

The cleanliness blew us away!! We had a great time at this property!

Really well kept and managed

It was a beautiful hotel. There was a major mix up with my check in which resulted in someone coming into my room in the middle of the night while I was sleeping. But management apologized, and gave me breakfast vouchers for the restaurant next door, along with a card, some fudge, and some cute mini bottles of sparkling cider. I understand accidents happen.

Beautiful place, new, very clean & quiet, welcoming staff, large room & public spaces, even hallways are large. Highly recommend

Never expected that this hotel would be so wonderful. From the moment we arrived we were treated so graciously. The rooms are spacious and clean and the lobby and hallways are open, immaculate and meticulously clean. I’d stay here again anytime I was in the area. The complimentary breakfast is fresh and plentiful.

Best hotel ever

Best hotel ever. Immaculate, great staff, so roomy, so beautiful. Dutch restaurant attached was fabulous !!!!

Stay was amazing! We read reviews prior to booking. It was every bit a 10 out of 10!

One of the nicest hotels I’ve been in in a while.

Our go-to hotel

Carlisle inn is our go-to hotel in the Sarasota area! The hotel exudes peacefulness, they play soft music throughout the hallways but low enough to where you can't hear it inside your room. The employees are fantastic and the Continental breakfast has some of the best donuts and baked goods around!

Continuing with my feedback from the previous one , this is an oasis in the desert. The staff really make you feel they are happy to see you and you are their guests , they are not faking their smiles or they are not pretenders. They are genuinely loving what they do and you feel it . If you wanna find some tranquility and inner peace from the everyday noise , just stay here like a getaway when you find the chance , definitely recommend it

Absolutely loved it! The hotel itself was stunning and the hospitality was out of this world, will be returning!!

I have never seen such a clean and hygiene hotel anywhere . The staff is super professional and very hospitable , always smiling and greeting . The tranquility and the positive energy in the hotel is just phenomenal. It has been an amazing stay and that is why I extended for another day . It is a truly amazing experience here , especially the great spiritual energy you sense all over the hotel

Great place to stay!

This is a top notch Hotel. Very clean and friendly with very nice decor! We would definitely stay there again!

Highly recommended

Very clean and comfortable

Wonderful place!

Incredibly nice and warm staff. Thank you so much!

Everything about this property is clean,comfortable,and safe. The room was spacious and clean with all the amenities you could need. Everyone was welcoming and professional. We truly enjoyed our stay.

Clean room. Cookies, danish treats offered. Wonderful Customer service.

Great place to stay!

We enjoy our stay here very much. Very large suite with many helpful amenities. Only small complaint was very little hot water on one morning! Breakfasts were great, and beds were very comfortable.

Very nice

Nice, clean hotel with very large rooms. Spacious bathroom, separate vanity. Very friendly staff. Free breakfast was fine. Afternoon cookies and all day coffee were added bonus. Good restaurant on the grounds.

The hotel is beautiful. Simple and quiet yet elegant. The pool and hot tub are wonderful.

This may be the cleanest hotel in Florida

We received the best service of any hotel we have stayed at since pre Covid. Everyone was so nice and friendly and the hotel is clean and beautifully decorated. We will definitely be back.