Andrews Inn & Garden Cottages

9.6

Exceptional

71 Guest reviews

9.6

Exceptional

71 Verified Reviews

Read all reviews

Cleanliness9.8/10

Service9.8/10

Comfort9.6/10

Condition9.8/10

Neighborhood9.8/10

Amenities9.6/10

We loved everything and will absolutely be returning! The one we were in was a cute 1 bedroom with french doors and a nice size bathroom. Decor was perfect. The pool is small but its perfect for the cottages. Entry to the property and room were by electronic code, the front porch was comfortable with the perfect amount of seating and tables. It looks like a little private community. Just loved the stay! The staff were so nice as well. This property is right off of Duval.

Everything about this property was such an unexpected surprise in all the best ways!! It is the most amazing little sanctuary in the heart of all the hustle & bustle of Key West. The most perfect quaint and romantic cottage style rooms with your own little porches or balconies. The outdoor area is a stunning oasis!! Perfect little dipping pool. Bar area with ice water and sodas. Even an outdoor restroom. It’s a huge perk that they offer free bikes on the property for you to take since pretty everywhere on Key West is bike able and probably preferred cuz parking is very hard to come by and/or expensive. I also need to make note of the excellent breakfast. Again, an unexpected surprise. They have an outdoor area setup in the morning with a coffee bar, fresh juice, pasties, hot breakfast items, incredible array of meats, cheeses and olives and everything seemed of the highest quality. It was so delicious!! And the staff were all so accommodating and super nice. The whole stay just exceeded our expectations. We loved everything about it!!

Loved staying here. Malaga room was cute, quaint and comfortable. Staff was amazing to us, great customer service. They went out of their way to accommodate us when we arrived tired and thirsty. If you have a car, there’s very limited parking and it’s inconvenient to get the car down the little street. Make sure to let them know ahead that you have a car and they will have you set up in the back. Then we left the car there and took a Lyft around Key West. We would definitely go back!

Great place

A very cute, small place with an island feel in a renovated old island home. Just a few steps off Duvall, yet very quite. Staff was wonderful. Room cozy, nice big bathroom. Super comfy bed. Issues: parking. There are only a few “free” parking spaces out front on the small narrow side street which dead-ends at their gate. Otherwise, you can pay to use one of the two spaces at the back alley, at $20/day. This seemed a little absurd, to pay extra to park, when our room, the Madrid, was almost $900 for two nights! Luckily, the place was not full so wasn’t a problem. Breakfast was all premade things but okay. They could have a little more tropical fruits instead of imported apples! But, they do have complementary big beach cruisers for guests to use. They have Avery small but comfy pool, which we used nightly. Overall, a solid 4 in some mentioned areas, and others a 5. Just depends what you are looking for overall. Since we like to get the flavor of a place and dont especially like larger hotels, it worked for us.

Th staff at the inn were very kind and helpful. It is a very quiet and relaxing place close to everything.The rooms are cazy and well decorated..Loved it and will definatly return!

Staff made feel like I’m the owner of the place. The greeted me by my name the moment I walked in they were kind and friendly. I highly recommend this spot it is truly magical. Super close to everything and they do provide a bicycle but I rented a scooter

Little Oasis in the Middle of It All!

We loved this little B&B! Super convenient to everything, but small and closed off from the outside world, with a lovely pool/lounging area to relax away from the craziness when you're done with it. Would definitely stay here again!

Great place

Very friendly staff. Great breakfast.

We liked everything about the property. The hosts were very attentive to our needs when we needed something. Great location also.

My husband and I loved this place. Our room was perfect for us 2. Loved the area so close to Duval Street. Will definitely stay here again.

Great place

Very friendly staff. Isabelle is a sweetheart! Free bikes, breakfast and happy hour are wonderful amenities. Great place to stay and will definitely return!

Book!

I live in Miami and has several experiences in different properties in Key West. This ones stands by far as the best one I have been yet. Everything is excellent: service, amenities, property and location! So just book!

Location was great, but parking place a little bit small and difficult to move in and out.

Quaint little house inn with lovely rooms, great service, and located close to all KW has to offer. No car necessary, but parking is available.

Little gem in Key West

Wonderful hosts! Very welcoming from start to end. Great location. Garden was lush and very private. Would recommend to anyone anytime. Best for couples

All everything was excellent. The personnal was freindly. We recommand for all people who wants to go at Key West. Super located

Right off of Duval, but still manages to be quiet and relaxing. The owner is almost always onsite and super friendly and helpful.

Had a wonderful stay at Andrews Inn. First, it was clean, we stayed in the Paris room, while it was small (I prefer cozy) it had enough room for two with a spacious bathroom, mini fridge and TV. Bed and pillows were super comfy. Pool, breakfast and happy hour very nice. Take advantage of their beach supplies vs renting snorkel equipment at the beach. We rented bikes from the Inn which got us anywhere within 5-10min. Great location as Mallory Square was abou15-20min walk, try Moondogs right around the corner. We will definitely stay here again on our next visit to the Keys.

Personal touch from the owner Michael was great, from the introduction to spending time chatting at pool.

Delightful, relaxing place in a great location. Hammock time with the cats was a highlight.

Very quaint and quiet. Close to Duval but still setene.

Liked the intimacy and courtyard/ pool area. Staff were very friendly and accommodating.

Everything was so personable this is a very intimate setting with 6 rooms and no children. Great location for entertainment and restaurants. Michael owner goes above and beyond in being the best host possible. One thing I did discover though is to book directly. I have been an avid Expedia user for 90% of our travel however will be booking directly in the future. After talking with 3 other guest I discovered I paid more than $200. over their cost they booked directly. I thought Expedia got their commission from the facilities, not true it is an expense passed on the users.

Lovely property. Very welcoming hosts. Would definitely return

This place was awesome. And the staff was extremely professional, friendly, and helpful!!!

Paradise found

We stayed one night in the Paris room. It was quaint, accommodating, and delightful environment. There are six different rooms to choose from. Breakfast and happy hour are included and enjoyable Mike and Albena have been your life long friends. Location is central yet quiet. Hemingway house is next door. Great restaurants in walking distance. We will be back!!!!

Awesome couple night away.

Great cozy place in the heard of Duval St. A quick walk to any of the popular places. Great location but secluded and quiet. We had a great time. The staff is super friendly. I hope we can do it again soon.

Wonderful Oasis in the heart of Key West! Clean, cozy and very private... owners are wonderful:)))

Clean room, fantastic breakfast, afternoon Happy Hour, location in Historic District within walking distance to most attractions, small pool to cool off in, parking provided - what more could you ask for?

Beautiful B & B. Great location in the middle of everything, but very quiet and secluded. Great staff. I would HIGHLY recomend

Amazing Stay

We had an amazing time here. Intimate, comfortable and chilled out vibe.

Hidden gem.

Amazing hidden gem in key west Florida, friendly staff with great free breakfast and happy hour, cant say enough, just amazing.

Very cute and comfortable bed & breakfast! I would definitely stay here again.

Lovely cottage, we will return. Everyone was gracious and was a wonderful experience.

Outstanding

Amazing!!!!. Very clean, private and quiet. Room and bed were comfortable. Breakfast was fantastic. Perfect for couples. Owners were very welcoming. I stayed 3 nights and I didn't want to leave. Can't wait to return.

Beautiful small inn, close to Duval Street but very quiet. Room was lovely, staff amazing. Good breakfasts and happy hour in the late afternoon. If we return to Key West in the future, we definitely will want to stay here. Can't recommend it highly enough.

Charming and accessible to all on island. Quiet location in the middle of all the action.

Quaint property and great location. Staff was super nice and would definitely stay again in the future

Great little place close to everything.

The staff were kind and attentive. We loved the decor. They have a complimentary happy hour and good breakfast with mimosas. It’s small and we learned a lot about new places to try from talking to the other guests. The Hemingway house (pool) was outside of our window which was pretty cool. We will book here again.

A Hidden Gem

This property is a hidden gem - perfectly situated, yet somehow still beautifully detached. It is quaint, well maintained and appropriately informal. Understandably, a lot of guests are repeat visitors and every new guest is likely to add to that list. Top drawer!!

Great B&B in Hemingway's backyard!

I did a search on Expedia for a B&B close to Hemingway's House in Key West so I'd know I was in Old Key West. Distance looked good, I booked. First morning I got up and looked out my bathroom window--right into Hemingway's backyard (his pool).Wow! Late check in went great with prior directions for exactly how it would work. Room was lovely. Pool was small but great for just sitting and cooling off--and it turned into a Jacuzzi! Breakfast was good. Parking was a little tight--two lots to choose from but a squeeze and right in someone else's front door (I guess the little houses weren't part of the inn). Great to be able to rent bikes right from the hotel.

A Key West gen!

A wonderful 4 night romantic week with in Key West with great hosts, a secluded hotel near everything (and sharing a common wall with the Hemingway home). Quiet and relaxing complete with cats by the pool and a hen with 5 young chicks parading by in the afternoon! A Key West treat!!

Hidden Key West Gem!

Our stay was just delightful here! It’s a hidden little oasis just off Duval Street. Very quiet and cozy. Adorable courtyard; daily Happy Hour. They even have books to read and sun lotion to use poolside, as well as ice tea and fruit infused water and ice all day to keep hydrated. We enjoyed a view of The Hemingway House’s backyard and grounds from our lanai. Manager Lisa was on hand to answer any questions during the day hours or make suggestions of places to visit. A lady I’ll just call ‘Z’ because I don’t know how to spell her name, laid out a magnificent spread daily for breakfast. She also cleaned our room daily and did a superb job. We met a lovely couple from the UK who visit every year. Lots of kitties here and there, even a mama hen and her chicks hung out nearby. We are already planning a return trip this summer.

Right on Duval Street; convenient to everything!

Amazing little hotel!!!!!! It has lovely décor and the breakfast is great. They also have 'free' Happy Hour. The owners/managers greet you themselves and truly want you to have a good stay. It has an atmosphere to meet other guest too.

Nice hotel in a great location, right off Duval St

Owners and staff were all very nice. Wonderful breakfast and happy hour. Great location.

Cozy Garden Overlook

Great location, cozy upstairs room with balcony overlooking Hemingway’s Garden. Friendly staff and entertaining kitties. Free off street parking. Highly recommend.

Great location and beautiful place

Great location and beautiful place

Exceeded expectations

This hotel is perfectly located near everything you will want to do in Key West. Our recent vacation was the perfect blend of relaxing in our spacious room, reading a book around the pool area, and walking around Key West to take in the sights and wonderful restaurants. We will definitely stay here again on our next visit to Key West.